5am At Mango Media Caribbean


Mango Media Caribbean

Much ado about journalism.

Posted At : June 12, 2009 9:38 AM | Posted By : Judette
Related Categories: Media

State of Play is a wonderful political thriller made more dramatic by the superb work of Australian actor, Russell Crowe, who plays  a long-haired, overweight, whiskey loving  reporter investigating the murder of  a young boy.  

What's great about this movie is that it is set in the office of a big city newspaper and it rolls out the  tensions that  are currently  being played out in newspapers across the globe between the editor and reporter,  the journalist  and blogger.  As a newspaper junkie, these interesting dichotomies are  reasons enough to go see this incredible movie.

In the subplot the tense relationship between bloggers and traditional journalists  is depicted. 

Young bloggers work in the same building but the context is  entirely different.   The traditional newsroom is overcrowded, dirty and old.  The reporters use computers that look like they been through several wars.  Crowe's character has an  office for instance that looks exactly like the  one my father  occupied over  his  five decades in the media.   It is stacked with paper, pin-ups of important but ancient stories and dusty, thumb-marked books that are never to be thrown away.

Rachel McAdams, is Crowe's nemesis. She's from new media and as if to make the contrast more startling  between herself and Crowe, the director makes her character crisp,  fresh, young. Her work area is certainly more modern than Crowe’s.  At first, when Adams asks Crowe for help, he resists. They are wary of each other, but in the end work together on a story of Watergate proportions. 

 

Their work ends up in print - before it makes it online.  

 

"When people read this story, they should have newsprint on their hands," explains McAdams' character.

 

I won't give much more of the plot away but there are some important  lessons  about journalism  that can be gleaned from what is clearly the best newspaper- themed movie to hit the screens in a very long time.

 

Investigative reporting is the bane of good newspapers: The movie's depiction of journalists as skeptical, resolute, and not easily duped was amazing. Stories and facts are checked and rechecked and then checked again.  That's a good lesson for anyone trying to spread information in our evolving media world. Traditional journalists maintain that the reason why  bloggers can never replace them is because  blogs come with hidden agendas and  facts are rarely ever second sourced. Editors, they claim, raise the right questions, launder  issues through the legal washing machine and send stories back  to be cross referenced. In the State of Play when the Crowe’s sources reveal a connection deeper than the murder of a young thief, his editor wants to assign him another experienced journalist to work on the story. The blogger is not experienced enough. The tactic  is later discarded but it still points scrooge like fingers to this question:  are bloggers resourced enough to do the kind of stoic detective grunge work  that made Woodward and Bernstein so respected? This  is a  genuine and  important question. In State of Play we have reason to believe that the answer is yes. But this is  still  a movie and I don’t think this is quite true ( as yet) in the real world.  

 

 

Can the divide be bridged?: At the end of the movie when  Crowe and Adams  exit the final scene there are several cutaways of how newspapers get printed and then distributed. The production is fascinating but you can't help but think it is a process whose time has come. State of Play movie paints a clear print versus online scenario, which in the end works because the print wins. This is not what's happening in the real world though.  Newspapers are folding by the dozens and the only way to stop the hemorrhage  is to have  more integration between the online and print world. One way to do so is for  journalists -print and online-  to see themselves as one.  Every reporter should be an online journalist, equipped  with the knowledge of how to upload stories, write headlines for search engine optimisation and work in online ecosystems. Bloggers ought to take a page or two of experience from traditional reporters in the areas of cultivating sources,  and investigating stories. What I am really trying to get at is there shouldn't be print people and online folks in one news operation. Each one should have one name, journalist. Editors have to begin to cultivate the mutual cordiality.

 

 

What to do before the real convergence?  In the movie there is an excellent  background story of the paper’s new owners trying to stop its  financial collapse.  They want the controversy and the  editor (the wonderful and ageless  Helen Mirren)  is under pressure to deliver  sensational news that will sell. While this part of the story remains obscure and only a secondary sub plot, in the  real world of journalism this issue is  on the front burner. Editors are under pressure to deliver and if they don’t then the fear of  job loss and business closure is real. But perhaps the real fear is that  editors  are now forced to spend so  much time trying to figure out how to keep the old model on life support that they aren’t able to devote the time  needed to  invent a new prototype that works better for everyone. We see that is Mirren’s worry in the movie as she struggles to  discover the right balance.

 

Make State of Play a must see movie. If you work in journalism or the media, I am interested in your comments. 

Comments (5) | Trackbacks (0) | Print | Send | del.icio.us | Digg It! Share

TrackBacks
There are no trackbacks for this entry.

Trackback URL for this entry:
http://www.mangomediacaribbean.com/blog/trackback.cfm?D4467F1F-3048-2D03-0A8D4BB3BF822B12

[Add Trackback]
Comments
[Add Comment]
Now I have to see the movie. From a purely IABC perspective is this a starting point from which we could explore Traditional versus New Media re the AGM guest speaker?
# Posted By Maria Rivas-McMillan | 6/14/09 3:11 PM
As a person studying new media and and online editor I agree with a large number of your comments. Looking forward to see which guest Speaker you decide on.
# Posted By maxie | 6/15/09 3:09 AM
Maria, you should see the movie.

The parts I described are only sub plots though but with all the tension in them you can imagine how wonderful the primary story lines are.

We can certainly use this post as a jump point for the conversation we are to have with our prospective speaker. It will be great to show clips from the movie as well. If you are not a news hound my guess is that you would have missed the sub plots; markekting/ comms folks might view any of the movie clips as fresh insights

I also have another post on this blog about how new and old media are responding to the changing landscapes that are today's newsrooms. To access use the search button on the left of the Mango Media Caribbean blog.
# Posted By Judette Coward Puglisi | 6/15/09 8:59 AM
Maxie, where do you study online media?
# Posted By Judette Coward Puglisi | 6/15/09 9:01 AM
It certainly was a brilliant movie. it really showed the difference between the old school and the new media. It emphasised the intencity and immediateness of the new media and how important the crossing of the two worlds was in the media house at present. All communicators should see it!
# Posted By Giselle West | 6/17/09 8:29 PM
[Add Comment]
About Us
Judette Coward Puglisi (MSc, Dip IR, BA), Managing Director. Find out more about us.
Navigation
About Judette Coward-Puglisi
Editorial guidelines
Mango Media Caribbean Facebook
Mango Media Caribbean Blog
Mango Media Caribbean Website
Archives By Subject
5th Summit of the Americas (1) [RSS]
Barbados Fertility Clinic, PR (1) [RSS]
Blogging (5) [RSS]
branding (1) [RSS]
Branding, Bmobile, TSTT, Digicel,Destra (1) [RSS]
Branding, Marketing (10) [RSS]
Branding, Social Media (1) [RSS]
Clients and Agencies (1) [RSS]
Communication (12) [RSS]
Communications Leadership (6) [RSS]
Communications Measurement (2) [RSS]
Communications, Leadership, Design (1) [RSS]
Communications, Leadership, Seth Goodin (1) [RSS]
Communications, Personal Branding (1) [RSS]
Cool Tools (2) [RSS]
Corporate Social Responsibility (1) [RSS]
Creativity, Communication (3) [RSS]
Crisis Communications (4) [RSS]
Customer service, Communication (2) [RSS]
Customer Service, Communication, PriceSmart, (1) [RSS]
Design (2) [RSS]
Design, Personal journey (1) [RSS]
Design, Russell Leonce, Christophe Pierre (1) [RSS]
Employee Communications (5) [RSS]
Entrepreneurship (37) [RSS]
Entrepreneurship, social media, strategy (1) [RSS]
Entrepreneurship, work life balance, joy at work (1) [RSS]
Events (2) [RSS]
Events, Media (1) [RSS]
Facebook, social networking, Diaspora (1) [RSS]
Facebook, social networking, friendship (1) [RSS]
Government Communications (7) [RSS]
Gulf of Mexico, oil spill, PR disaster, BP (1) [RSS]
IABC Trinidad and Tobago (5) [RSS]
IABC Trinidad and Tobago, Social Media, (1) [RSS]
IABC, Communications, Leadership (1) [RSS]
Innovation, Entrepreneurship (2) [RSS]
Inter cultural communications (2) [RSS]
Journalism (3) [RSS]
Leadership (8) [RSS]
Marketing (15) [RSS]
Media (7) [RSS]
Media Trinidad and Tobago (2) [RSS]
Media Trinidad and Tobago, CNN, Sam Feist (2) [RSS]
Media, Leadership (4) [RSS]
Observations of and from life on the Web (1) [RSS]
Personal (23) [RSS]
Personal branding (5) [RSS]
Personal, Productivity (3) [RSS]
Personal, Productivity, Branding (1) [RSS]
Political Communications (4) [RSS]
political communications, crisis communications, (0) [RSS]
Political Communications, Summit of the Americas (2) [RSS]
PR, Jeff Jarvis, Google (1) [RSS]
Public Relations (16) [RSS]
Public Relations Trinidad and Tobago (26) [RSS]
Public Relations Trinidad and Tobago, Speeches, (2) [RSS]
Public Relations, Corporate Photography (1) [RSS]
Running a successful PR firm is damn hard. There a (1) [RSS]
Social Media (28) [RSS]
Social media, foursquare (1) [RSS]
Work Life balance for communicators (7) [RSS]
Recent Comments

What age brings in business
JosieH said: WOW! Would you believe that as I was reading your previous Entrepreneurial posts, I kept wondering t... [More]

Designer Claudia Pegus to make bold statement at Fashion Week after being held at gunpoint
Artavan said: There was a time when crime affected nameless faces, people we didn't know, now crime is in our back... [More]

Facebook Places, have checked in yet?
Celia said: It is the way of the future, or so they say. So much time is already spent on Facebook and other Soc... [More]

Facebook Places, have checked in yet?
q said: seems like way too much exposure for me. only if i find some way to include it in my work i will con... [More]

Ideas are Cheap and Plentiful
judette Coward-Puglisi said: Tameika timing is everything. Ideas need time to percolate and we need time to get over our fears. S... [More]

Most Popular Entries
Fattening Your Ideas File, My Way.
Success..
Top Five PR Reasons for Obama's move into the White House
Why I Love PR
Futurist Says Marketers Need to Embrace Social Media
Most Commented Entries
Mr Manning's cancer announcement causes journalists to fall silent
An olive branch Mr Prime Minister? How a communicator would advise Mr. Manning
Top Five PR Reasons for Obama's move into the White House
Is it just me, or was this a crazy moment in marketing?
PR fiasco makes me wonder will we ever learn?
Search

Google Search

The Web
Mango Media Blog
Subscribe
Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog.

RSS
Blogroll
Seth Godin's Blog
Media Futurist- Gerd Leonhard
Marketing Rooster
Richard Edelman's Blog
Lee Odden
Save the Media
© 2010 Mango Media Caribbean